Insider news & Analysis in Iran

By Iran News Update Staff 

EXTENSION OF NUCLEAR TALKS

The extension of  nuclear negotiations between Iran and the P5+1 was announced. Diplomats from most of the parties involved have maintained that there is still a great deal of distance between the contrary positions, but that progress is being made, which suggests that mutual agreement may be attainable within the next six months or so.

THE VALUE OF EXTENSION

Of course, despite the prevalence of criticism in Congress and the media for President Obama’s approach to the Iran situation, there is plenty of support for the extension of talks among some analysts and commentators. In an article at the Huffington Post, Elie Jacobs of the Truman National Security Project makes the point that the options are limited for obtaining a final solution to the nuclear issue. Very likely, he argues, it is a choice between diplomacy and war.

Furthermore, Jacobs suggests that the triumph of diplomacy would be the fulfilment of an effective sanctions program, which has so far served the specified purpose of bringing Iran to the negotiating table. From this point of view, as difficult as the continued discussions may be and as obstinate as the Islamic Republic has been, an extension is worthwhile simply by virtue of the fact that it gives diplomacy a chance and delays any future need for the US to take military action.

Meanwhile, an article at The Diplomat responds to the fact that there is significant pressure for such military action in American policy circles. The author, Zachary Keck, makes the perhaps surprising claim that Iranian hardliners approve of the influence of these “Iran hawks,” because they may help Iran to win the ongoing “blame game” between the two sides. Keck says that Iran’s goal in the negotiations is to either win a favorable nuclear deal or to make the United States look bad in the process of trying to do so.

Keck’s assessment has the Iranian regime benefitting whether the talks succeed or fail at this point. But it also suggests that an excessively hawkish approach may cause the US to sacrifice its ability to secure significant restrictions on the Islamic Republic’s nuclear program. This is only possible through negotiations, Keck points out, if economic sanctions have credibility. That is, contrary to the desires of some Iran hawks, they must be suspended or removed when they fulfill their stated purpose, which is strictly the curtailment of Iran’s nuclear weapons development.

INCENTIVES VERSUS PUNISHMENTS

But the idea of suspending sanctions in response to verifiable concessions is also contrary to the way they might still be used according to an article by Reuters, with the headline, “Iran nuclear negotiations are going so badly that the West may ease sanctions early.” The plan would reportedly abandon the idea of waiting for confirmation of Iranian compliance, and would instead suspend sanctions incrementally in a way that allowed them to be quickly re-imposed if Iran does fail to comply.

The article describes this as a goodwill gesture towards Iran and quotes one diplomat as saying, “It’s all meant to be reciprocal.” However, many analysts have observed Iran to be the intransigent party in these negotiations – a situation that may be seen by many as not warranting goodwill. Certainly, this is the view of much of the US Congress, which is expected to react aggressively against any plan that tries to front-load sanctions relief excessively.

The practicality of this plan may also be in doubt. Reuters seems to indicate that the plan depends upon the perceived reluctance of global banking institutions to overstep their allowances under a sanctions relief scheme. But this reluctance may not be as severe as some believe, since a handful of Western banks have already defied sanctions, and businesses and governments are both considering normalization of these activities in order to gain a competitive edge in the Iranian market.

If sanctions are alleviated even more readily, as an incentive for Iranian cooperation, rather than a punishment for non-cooperation, it may give the impression of irreversible goodwill towards the Islamic Republic. In the wake of the BNP Paribas scandal that caused the French bank to be fined 9 billion dollars for its sanctions evasion, the chairman of the French Senate’s Finance Committee expressed concern that the US would inevitably remove sanctions, but was positioning itself to gain the most from that eventual move.

Similarly, pending European Parliament challenges, fourteen Iranian entities were recently de-listed by a European court as sanctions targets. According to the Wall Street Journal, this has just allowed Iran to reenter the global shipping market after four years of being kept out of it, unable to obtain shipping containers due to sanctions and economic isolation. 

As evidenced by this development, suspension of sanctions may have the effect of incentivizing Western institutions to do business with Iran. This may in turn cause them to have the opposite of their intended effect, in that they will give Iran less incentive to comply with an agreement. That is, Iran may be able to benefit enough from temporary relief that it will not strictly need suspensions to be made permanent. Already, reports have indicated that the release of capital to the Iranian market has been larger than anticipated.

COMPARING MULTIPLE PERSPECTIVES

The consideration of a possibly more generous sanctions relief scheme, along with the reactions to it, goes to show that there is still a great deal of uncertainty surrounding any final deal that might be created. But it also makes clear that there are powerful forces that are committed to seeing that that deal is a possibility. Against this background, there has apparently been a new outpouring of analyses of what that deal must look like in order to defend Western interests.

The Bipartisan Policy Center released an infographic on Thursday titled “Evaluating a nuclear deal with Iran.” It brings together the demands and recommendations that have been specified on various key points by several different organizations: the US Congress, the P5+1 negotiating team, the Brookings Institution, the International Crisis Group, and the Jewish Institute for National Security Affairs.

Furthermore, the infographic compares these expectations to the known situation prior to the signing of the Joint Plan of Action, and during the interim period that is now drawing to a close. Although the document is missing information about specific Iranian demands – such as a 19 times expansion of its enrichment capability – it still helps the reader to visualize the distance between the current state of Iran’s nuclear program and the minimum acceptable situation according to each of these groups. The gap is significant, as can be seen here:

http://bipartisanpolicy.org/sites/default/files/files/IranNuclearDeal.pdf

 

 

 

 

Iranian Opposition

Recognizing Iran regime’s real opponents

Recognizing Iran regime’s real opponents

By INU Staff The Iran threat is complicated and it is worsened by the misinformation and a lack of true reporting by the internat...

Time to support the quest of Iranian People for Regime Change

Time to support the quest of Iranian People for Regime Change

By INU Staff INU - After years and years of mismanagement and widespread corruption, the Iranian economy is in tatters and the pe...

Infightings

Iran: Further media restrictions to impact 2020 parliamentary elections

Iran: Further media restrictions to impact 2020 parliamentary elections

By INU Staff INU - The Iranian parliamentary elections are due to be held in just over a year on 21st February 2020. In preparati...

Iran: Supreme Leader Tries to Avoid Public Backlash Following Flooding Crisis

Iran: Supreme Leader Tries to Avoid Public Backlash Following Flooding Crisis

By Siavosh The people of Iran have been dealing with the aftermath of torrential rain and huge storms that have resulted in flash...

Nuclear

Iran Regime’s Nuclear Ultimatum May Have Opposite of Intended Effect on European Policy

Iran Regime’s Nuclear Ultimatum May Have Opposite of Intended Effect on European…

By Edward Carney Although the European signatories to the 2015 Iran nuclear deal remain broadly committed to upholding it a year ...

Iran angry at France over tweets regarding nuclear deal

Iran angry at France over tweets regarding nuclear deal

By INU Staff INU - Iran's Deputy Foreign Minister Abbas Araqchi has said that tweets by Gerard Araud, the French Ambassador to th...

Human rights

Two Months After Nationwide Flooding, Iran Still Withholds Relief, Attacks Victims

Two Months After Nationwide Flooding, Iran Still Withholds Relief, Attacks Victi…

By Edward Carney United Nations Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs and the European Civil Protection Mechanism h...

Ramadan Marks Accelerated Repression of Iran’s Religious Minorities, Secular Youth

Ramadan Marks Accelerated Repression of Iran’s Religious Minorities, Secular You…

By Mahmoud Hakamian On Wednesday, Iran Human Rights Monitor reported upon a raid that occurred at a restaurant located on the cam...

Women

Tensions Growing Between Female Activists and Sexist Iranian Institutions

Tensions Growing Between Female Activists and Sexist Iranian Institutions

By Edward Carney On Monday, the Center for Human Rights in Iran reported upon the sentencing of a female political prisoner by th...

Fearing Arrest, Iran’s Female Boxer Shines Light on Women’s Rights Issues

Fearing Arrest, Iran’s Female Boxer Shines Light on Women’s Rights Issues

By Edward Carney On Sunday, Al Monitor published an article examining the case of Sadaf Khadem, a female Iranian boxer who made h...

Economy

Iran’s export to Iraq drop by 50%

Iran’s export to Iraq drop by 50%

By INU Staff INU - Iraq has significantly reduced its imports from the Iranian Regime in the past month, according to an economic...

Iran Regime’s economic problems caused by military interference

Iran Regime’s economic problems caused by military interference

By INU Staff INU - Iran’s economy is set to contract by 6% in 2019, while also facing 40% inflation, according to the Internation...

Sanctions

Details of US-Iran Escalation Remain Hazy, but Sanctions Remain the Focus

Details of US-Iran Escalation Remain Hazy, but Sanctions Remain the Focus

By Edward Carney In the midst of escalating tensions between Iran and the United States, Western media was filled with inconsiste...

Turkey complies with U.S. regarding imports of Iranian oil

Turkey complies with U.S. regarding imports of Iranian oil

By INU Staff INU - Last year, the U.S. State Department announced that it would be expecting all foreign countries to reduce thei...

Middle East

White House Confident in its Ability to Deter Iranian Threats

White House Confident in its Ability to Deter Iranian Threats

By Edward Carney Escalating tensions between the United States of America and the Islamic Republic of Iran were prominently featu...

The IRGC and Catching the Mullahs off Guard

The IRGC and Catching the Mullahs off Guard

By Dr Salem Al Ketbi The Iranian mullahs have no other project than the sectarianist, expansionist plans of the Iranian Revolutio...

Terrorism

Iran behind attacks on ships in Middle East

Iran behind attacks on ships in Middle East

By INU Staff INU - Earlier this week, a U.S. official announced that the recent attacks carried out in the Middle East were order...

As Iran’s Provocations Grow, the White House Insists the Danger is Well-Managed

As Iran’s Provocations Grow, the White House Insists the Danger is Well-Managed

By Edward Carney On Tuesday, the UK’s Express newspaper declared that concerns about the potential for war had increased further ...

Iran Protests 2018

Free Iran 2018 Gathering - 30 June 2018 - Villepinte, Paris

latest INU tweet

GETTING TO KNOW IRAN'S REVOLUTIONARY GUARDS

THE STORY OF THE 1988 MASSACRE IN IRAN

Copyright © 2018 Iran News Update